Welcome to BigFlax.com!
![]()
April 30, 2005
So, I've been listening to Songs for Silverman pretty much nonstop since it arrived on Tuesday. Is it good? Oh yes. Following is the review.
Ben Folds has built much of his career on piano-driven, pop-rock songs, most of which tell little slice-of-life stories in their lyrics. It's a pretty narrow category, to be sure, but Folds is pretty unquestionable in his mastery of it. His biggest hit to date, "Brick" (released with Ben Folds Five on 1997's Whatever and Ever Amen, the best of the group's four albums), was about taking a girlfriend to get an abortion - as Folds himself has said, there is no intent to make a political statement, despite the charged nature of the subject; it's just a song about two scared kids dealing with the most emotional and difficult moment of their lives up until that point. And that's not even Folds' best song by a long shot.
2001's Rockin' the Suburbs, Folds' first solo album following the breakup of the Five, followed similar trends lyrically but had a bit of a different sound overall, leaning a bit more electronic than the Five ever really had (though Folds' interest in it could be seen in his 1998 solo album Fear of Pop, Volume One, which even die-hard fans tend to find fairly unlistenable). While Suburbs produced a number of great songs, something about it was a little unsatisfying overall. Seeming to recognize this, Folds spent nearly four years working on a followup, releasing three EPs - Speed Graphic, Sunny 16, and Super D in the interval.
It can probably be considered a good thing that the most disappointing aspect - and possibly the only disappointing aspect - of Songs for Silverman, which came out on Tuesday, is its number of tracks: despite the four years, there are only 11, and one is a reworked version of a track that appeared on Speed Graphic. On the other hand, fans of Folds have gotten fifteen tracks out of his three EPs, and 11 of those were brand-new Folds-written songs (the remaining four were covers, though it bears noting that Folds covers tend to be uniquely enjoyable). Factoring out the overlap, Folds has produced 21 new songs in four years, which is not to be sniffed at. Also important is the average length of the songs - the album clocks in around 45 minutes, which is pretty much par for the course.
More importantly, Folds is in top form here. The songs are appropriately piano-driven (there is no "Rockin' the Suburbs" on this album), with strings thrown in here and there to solid effect. The stories (dealing in several cases with parts of relationships) are mostly strong with a couple that are even better and a couple that are a little more marginal. Here, then, a song-by-song review of the album, ranked in order of how much I like them.
11. Prison Food (track 11)
There's nothing wrong with "Prison Food", as there's really nothing wrong
with any track on the album. But it's pretty unremarkable. The tune is fine
but unspectacular, and the lyrics are a bit more vague than much of Folds' work.
It's not that they're bad so much as that they don't really sound like him - they feel
like they could have been written by pretty much anyone. While in general that's not
a criticism, I consider Folds a unique enough songwriter that I like to see a little more
from him - and certainly we do see more, pretty much everywhere else on the album.
10. Give Judy My Notice (track 7)
In a straight comparison, this song is probably better than the next two, but I have to
dock it points, as "Notice" is just a reworked version of a song from the first
EP, Speed Graphic. This in and of itself wouldn't be so bad except that the
EP version is significantly better - while that track is pretty much just Folds and a
piano, and doesn't actually feature the title until the end of the song (a much more
effective use of it, to my mind), this song features drums, bass, and backing vocals, as
well as repetitions of the title, which don't work as well considering the subject (Folds
explains to a girlfriend that he's tired of having his love exploited when she doesn't
really love him, then asks a faceless third party to "give Judy my notice").
It's still a fine song lyrically, but the other version is superior in every way.
9. Time (track 10)
One of two songs on the album whose chorus involves a somewhat hokey play with words (here
it's "time takes time, you know"). It plays better in context, but it's
not great. Fortunately, the rest of the song is good - the opening piano riff is one
of the album's best, and the lyrics, while still a tad vague, are relatively concrete in
their meaning (Folds sardonically granting someone, presumably an ex-girlfriend, license
to "think of me any way you want - I can be the problem if that's easier" after
a breakup). Folds has a way of making exceedingly bitter, sarcastic lyrics sound
just as good as anything else, which we'll see a couple more times. Interesting note
on this song: Weird Al Yankovic contributes backing vocals, evidently returning the favor
after Folds played the piano track on "Why Does This Always Happen To Me", a
track on Yankovic's last album. You'd never have known it was Al if the liner notes
didn't tell you, though.
8. Sentimental Guy (track 9)
Though it too references lost love, there's a marked difference between "Sentimental
Guy" and either of the previous two tracks - while both of those are rather acidic in
their final analysis, "Sentimental Guy" offers a self-portrait of someone
scarred by a loss (what the loss was due to is unclear, as is whether Folds is referencing
a friend, lover, or family member) but sad rather than angry. Folds describes how he
"used to be a sentimental guy", but this changed with the loss of the person
he's singing to, who "drifted far away". Not angered by this, Fold's
"Guy" is depressed in a sort of whimsical way, as he notes "Now I don't
miss anyone, I don't miss anything - what a shame". The tune itself has a kind
of upbeat lilt to it that doesn't quite match the lyrical content, but it's not like Folds
is necessarily known for always matching the two (Whatever and Ever Amen's
"Song for the Dumped" being the classic example of this).
7. Gracie (track 5)
Though I don't want to fault Folds for writing songs about the current things in his life
- his wife and children, particularly - instead of the endless parade of ex-girlfriends
who creep in everywhere (to be fair, I have no idea how many of his songs in that vein are
autobiographical or even semi-autobiographical, but I'm sure a good number derive at least
partially from his own experiences), songs like this, while good, can be a bit
grating. The other noteworthy example is "The Luckiest", the last track on
Suburbs and an unabashed declaration of love directly to his wife. It's kind
of cute, but it's also a bit sappy, and his earnestness overwhelms his usual songwriting
sensibilities (which I'll explain more later). "You will always have a part of
me / Nobody else is ever gonna see" is sweet, but so few of Folds' songs actually
sound like this that it's a little weird to hear it. The tune, thankfully, is
wonderful, and the closing piano notes and string flourishes are gorgeous.
6. Jesusland (track 3)
Since he spent much of his life in the South, it's interesting to hear Folds go after it
as he does here. Hiding behind a typically evasive melody are lyrics like "Out
the gate you go and never stop, past dollar stores and wig shops"; though he's hardly
explicit in the condemnation, it's hard to make much else out of the portrait he paints,
and the moniker "Jesusland" certainly doesn't seem intended as flattery.
(Officially, there's nothing in the song that identifies the subject as the American
South, but come on.) Much of the song is just description, but the third verse's
lyrics include the following: "They drop your name, but no one knows your face /
Billboards quoting things you never said / You hang your head and pray for
Jesusland". The "you" there would appear to be God himself - which,
if true, is a pretty big slam on the region and its politics. Of course, I'm fine
with it.
5. You to Thank (track 2)
The lyrics of "You to Thank" are truly fascinating - on the one hand, it's a
humorous depiction of getting married in Vegas while drunk ("By the time the buzz was
wearing off, we were standing out on the sidewalk / With our tattoos that looked like
rings"), but on the other hand it's a strangely bittersweet tale of trying to fake
one's way through a crumbling relationship ("For moms and dads, not a clue to be had
/ We put on a pretty good act / And they seemed to all need to believe it"), and
possibly one that should never have existed in the first place. (It's easy to
picture the titular "You" as just a friend who had become more due to the
accidental marriage, as opposed to a girlfriend he just shouldn't have married while
drunk.) Typically, the music is pretty upbeat, and the chorus sounds great.
4. Trusted (track 6)
The lyrics to "Trusted" read like words composed by someone who just realized
that his relationship is not what he thought it was. When Folds asks "Didn't
you know we're as close as we can be?", he's asking it because the woman he's
addressing has been reading his diary because she doesn't trust him. The song's
general thesis is that while everyone would like to know what their partner is thinking
all the time, it's not really going to happen, which is why trust is important - and as
Folds sings "It seems to me if you can't trust, you can't be trusted" (the other
play on words I referenced back in the "Time" review), we can see the lack of
trust souring the relationship from both ends. Of course, the melody is still at
best moderately reflective of this, though it's a great one.
3. Bastard (track 1)
It's an odd choice to open your album with a song that's five and a half minutes long, and
for that matter one whose title is "Bastard", but this song grew on me faster
than any on the album. First, it's got a great melody. But more than that, it
has killer lyrics - it's simultaneously a story about an old man's passing and an attack
on the arrogance of youth. Folds notes that getting older involves gaining the
ability to recognize that you don't know it all, singing "'The Whiz Man' will never
fit you like 'The Whiz Kid' did" and "The more you know, you know you don't know
shit". Smart and acerbic without being too savage, the song actually finds more
empathy for the titular bastard than for the "young man" of the second verse.
2. Late (track 8)
There may not be all that many songs that were written by one musician in tribute to the
passing of another, but I'm sure this is one of the best. Folds' elegy to Elliott
Smith, it combines a melancholy but gorgeous melody with some of the best examples of what
makes Folds' songs what they are lyrically. The lyrics are not a fawning ode to
Smith's songwriting genius or greatness as a human being - they're an honest look at what
Smith meant to Folds. "Elliott, man, you played a fine guitar - and some dirty
basketball," Folds sings in the third verse. He's not afraid to talk about
human frailty either - "It's too late / Don't you know it's been too late for a long
time", he sings in the chorus, a reference to Smith's personal struggles that
apparently led to his suicide. An honest tribute to a friend, the song is beautiful,
bringing me to the verge of tears the last time I listened to it.
1. Landed (track 4)
As beautiful as "Late" is, I couldn't give up on "Landed", which I
found immediately addicting right from the moment I heard the first chorus as a 30-second
song sample. It may be the best song Folds has released as a solo artist -
melodically gorgeous, with perfect lyrics in which he sings to an ex-girlfriend that he's
back in town after breaking up with the girl he'd started dating following the end of
their relationship. Considering the dodginess of that subject on basic principles,
the song is far more poignant than it has any right to be, all of which is owed to the way
Folds works the lyrics. "I'm just now finding out what it was all about,"
he says of the older relationship, then describes how the other girl moved him to the west
coast, "away from everyone," and "she never told me that you called / Back
when I was still, I was still in love." Despite the strangeness of its
circumstances, "Landed" describes them perfectly, making the lyrics as affecting
as anything on the album. A non-album version, made available for download to people
who bought the CD package through Folds' site, features strings at the beginning and
throughout the song, and it's actually even better.
Final album grade: 95/100. Its "worst" songs are
exceedingly listenable, and its best songs are fabulous. That's a great album.
![]()
April 24, 2005
I know what I said last week about acting like you've been there before (I can read it right below this too), and we didn't even win. But my stats went through the roof. I'm trying not to make too big a deal out of it, but it's not often you go to a tournament and come back having set personal records for points in a round and team points in a round. Well, now that it's actually happened, I can act like I've been there before next time. Anyway, 2005 Duck Bowl results.
![]()
April 18, 2005
So you already know we got fourth place. Had this happened a couple years ago, I'd probably be bouncing off the walls, but really, act like you've been there before. I'll save the bouncing for if I ever play on a team that wins. Anyway, here's the TRASHionals recap.
![]()
April 17, 2005
We got fourth place! More detailed recap to come when I'm not ready to pass out.
![]()
April 13, 2005
Well, I'm a little disappointed, if not entirely surprised, by the lack of comments so far. On the movie message board I post at, the top ten list was probably actually the recipient of the most complaints, so let's see if that stirs anyone up. But first:
Honorable Mentions
Each one of these films got a score of B+ (75/100) or better, but wasn't quite good enough to make the final Top Ten.
The Motorcycle Diaries

A little too rah-rah-communism for my liking, but its gorgeous to watch, it has a beautiful score, and Bernal is magnificent. If you can pretend its not about Che Guevara, its a near-perfect road movie.
Hero

Again, went a little too far with the up-with-communism ending, but before that it features sublime cinematography and a decent Rashomon-like plot.
Miracle

A little too prosaic to be a great sports film, but its still a pretty good one. Kurt Russell does a great job as Herb Brooks.
Collateral

In some ways its a bad action film dressed up to look like a good one, but I was sucked in by it. Cruise and Foxx are good, and the plot is just dense enough that its worth hanging on to the whole way.
Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban

Easily the best of the series so far. The time travel plot is neat and
Cuarons lack of desire to show every single scene like
![]()
April 11, 2005
With the worst movies of the year behind us, it's time for a shorter list: that of the most disappointing movies of the year. Even though I saw 50, I couldn't have legitimately filled out a ten-spot list for this one, so you'll have to settle for half.
The Five Biggest Disappointments of 2004
5
Team America: World Police

4
I © Huckabees

When I saw the trailer, I knew that this would either be a very interesting film or one that was nothing but quirks. I hoped for the former; I got the latter. Essentially a parade of increasingly strange setpieces, Huckabees doesn't care whether its characters are real people or cardboard cutouts (they're mostly the latter) or whether its pop-philosophical machinations make any sense or not (they mostly don't). It's somewhat fun to watch in a detached sense, but after a while Russell's attempts to pass quirks off as existentialism just get frustrating. The film ends up seeming far less interested in the mysteries of life that it does in being a 21st century version of an Ionesco play that's playing a game of one-upmanship with its own weirdness at every turn. In the end, Huckabees is long on quirk and far too short on ideas.
3
The Terminal

Finding humor in the man-stuck-in-airport plot would have worked pretty well as satire, which is why The Terminal doomed itself by being so irritatingly earnest. There's certainly an interesting story behind the concept, but virtually none of it makes it onscreen - Spielberg is far more interested in telling a story featuring useless caricatures and a horrible love interest. The actors are game but the characters are almost uniformly awful, as not one of them seems to behave as a real person might, and while the direction and set design are skillful enough, they're put in service of relentless mediocrity. It's not an awful film, but it's not an especially good one either, and its faults end up outweighing its positives. The story of Viktor Navorski was worth telling, yes, but it was also worth telling better.
2
A Very Long Engagement

As a huge Amélie fan, I had high hopes for a re-teaming of Tautou and Jeunet, but Engagement lacks much of what made its predecessor so brilliant. The obsession to detail that made the 2001 film and its characters so vivid blows up in Jeunets face when he tries it again here; there are too many characters to describe and he refuses to prioritize. The upshot is that we end up learning more about a group of relatively insignificant soldiers than we do about Tautous Mathilde, which goes a long way towards dooming the films intentions. Its half a rumination on the craziness of war and half a love story with an emphasis on the strength of hope, but the characters in the love story get woefully little attention as characters, making it difficult to care that much, and this hurts the war story as it is mostly a vehicle for the love story with a few ideas added in. Its beautiful to look at, but Engagement never forges the personal connection that Amélie did, and its neither magical enough to match up to its predecessor nor sober enough to avoid the comparison.
1
The Life Aquatic with Steve Zissou

Wes Anderson has made his name with films featuring quirky, sometimes
unlikable characters whom the audience comes to care about anyway through his light,
subtle humor and general tenderness. The Life Aquatic, however, plays like the film
![]()
April 10, 2005
With pretty much only Ray and the I-didn't-see-the-first-one-so-why-see-this Before Sunset standing out as major 2004 domestic-release movies I have yet to see, it's time to compile some year-end lists, which I'll do one at a time. This first post will feature the ten worst films of the year (that I saw). Feel free to discuss the lists in the forum; do remember before flaming me that I only claim this as my opinion, not some sort of fact, but I hope that the capsules explain why I picked the lists I did.
The Ten Worst Films of 2004
10
House of Flying Daggers

I dont know that this film really deserves inclusion on a worst of the year list, but until I stumble across something truly awful, its probably going to hold the 10 spot. Though it starts in promising fashion with a visually dazzling, if entirely too long, setpiece, the film from there does about everything wrong its capable of doing. The plot contorts itself so many times that it ends up breaking its own back, and the love triangle thats pretty much wholly invented for the final half hour never works. Worst of all is a Titanic-in-China ending that acts like characters about whom we knew very little and were given only marginal reason to care were the ultimate star-crossed lovers, and then plays a sappy ballad over the end credits. Its so over-the-top it could only have worked as parody, but its not, so its just insulting.
9
Around the World in Eighty Days

8
The Polar Express

7
Kill Bill Volume Two

6
Napoleon Dynamite

5
The Forgotten

4
Shark Tale

3
Dogville

2
Win a Date with Tad Hamilton!

1
Wicker Park

![]()
April 10, 2005
With participation relatively minimal and only a few correct answers, here are the answers to the game of the April 2 update.
First, those that were right:
3) Blink 182 - All the Small Things (Alma gets this one)
5) Elton John - Your Song (this is definitely one for Alma)
12) The Beatles - For No One (the answer's on the site, of course, but
Alma got in first!)
16) U2 - Bad (I am inclined to call this a lucky guess on the part of
Greg, though it does match Craig's)
17) Van Halen - Jump (Dad, via e-mail, knows that the '84 Cubs were
enough to put this one on top)
19) The Who - Baba O'Riley (Dad again, most likely remembering that this
is one of my few favorite songs ever)
And now the ones no one got:
1) Ben Folds - Still Fighting It
2) Ben Folds Five - Underground. Some good guesses, including One
Angry Dwarf and 200 Solemn Faces, but no one had the right one, off BFF's first
album.
4) Fastball - Out of My Head
6) Fountains of Wayne - Stacy's Mom. Frankly, I'm shocked no one got this
one.
7) Guster - X-Ray Eyes. Some good guesses, but this one was hard.
8) Led Zeppelin - Over the Hills and Far Away. It would have been Stairway
probably as recently as six months ago, but this one was tough.
9) Queen - Fat Bottomed Girls
10) Snow Patrol - Run
11) Steely Dan - My Old School
13) The New Pornographers - From Blown Speakers. Good guesses from Greg and
Dad, who both picked Neko Case songs (and I'm on record somewhere, though maybe not here,
as loving her voice), but in the end I had to go with this one.
14) The Rolling Stones - 19th Nervous Breakdown. Gimme Shelter,
Dad's choice, is probably second.
15) Tom Petty and the Heartbreakers - Free Fallin'. Another one of the few
where my choice was actually fairly conventional, yet no one guessed it anyway.
18) Weezer - El Scorcho. Had Leah shown up she might have known this one.
20) Jimi Hendrix - The Wind Cries Mary
![]()
April 3, 2005
Now that a couple days have gone by and the likelihood of it being an awful April Fools joke has subsided, a melancholy Happy Trails to Mitch Hedberg. Once referred to as the "next Seinfeld" because of his style of observational humor, Hedberg was probably closer to Steven Wright in terms of his dry delivery and frequent one-liners. I had the good fortune to see him at Northwestern last year and while it wasn't his best show, it was certainly very funny. He was apparently born with a heart defect that contributed to his death (he died in a hotel room in Livingston, New Jersey, not 20 minutes from my old house), though I suspect drugs and/or alcohol may have helped a little bit, even if they weren't the outright cause. What surprised me most was that he was as old as 37, an age he certainly didn't project with his stoner demeanor. Here's the Sun-Times listing of the obit; here are a few of my favorite jokes:
"I played golf... I did not get a hole in one, but I did hit a guy. That's way more satisfying. You're supposed to yell 'Fore!' but I was too busy mumbling, 'There ain't no way that's gonna hit him.'"
"When someone hands you a flyer, it's like they're saying 'Here... you throw this away.'"
"I like rice. Rice is great if you're hungry and want 2,000 of something."
"An escalator can never break. It can only become stairs. You would never see an 'Escalator Temporarily Out of Order' sign, just 'Escalator Temporarily Stairs. Sorry for the convenience.'"
"I was walking by a dry cleaners at 3 am and there was a sign that said 'Sorry, We're Closed'. You don't have to be sorry. It's 3 am, and you're a dry cleaner. It would be ridiculous for me to expect you to be open. I'm not gonna come by at 10 and say, 'Hey, I was here at 3 am and you guys were closed... somebody owes me an apology.'"
![]()
April 2, 2005
For those who may have been keeping an eye on the Challenge but not reading the page, Craig
won. Drew fell short due to the outcome of a specific game for the third year in a
row, much to his chagrin.
Speaking of Craig, the following is ripped both from his blog and
Leah's LJ. Basically, I name 20 musical artists I like, and you guess which is my
favorite song by each of them. One of these is easy because it's on the site... but
the rest, I'll be interested to see if people are right or even try. I'll update
correct answers here.
1) Ben Folds
2) Ben Folds Five
3) Blink 182 - All the Small Things (Alma gets this one)
4) Fastball
5) Elton John - Your Song (this is definitely one for Alma)
6) Fountains of Wayne
7) Guster
8) Led Zeppelin
9) Queen
10) Snow Patrol
11) Steely Dan
12) The Beatles - For No One (the answer's on the site, of course, but
Alma got in first!)
13) The New Pornographers
14) The Rolling Stones
15) Tom Petty and the Heartbreakers
16) U2 - Bad (I am inclined to call this a lucky guess on the part of
Greg, though it does match Craig's)
17) Van Halen - Jump (Dad, via e-mail, knows that the '84 Cubs were
enough to put this one on top)
18) Weezer
19) The Who - Baba O'Riley (Dad again, most likely remembering that this
is one of my few favorite songs ever)
20) Jimi Hendrix
![]()
There's more! View last month's updates.
![]()
![]()
Thanks to Verio for the domain and my parents for paying it off.
Want to send me mail? Here.
BigFlax.com is probably not legitimately copyrighted under the laws of any country. Just don't steal stuff and claim it was yours, please.
© 2005 Big Flax Enterprises
This page last updated: Sunday, May 01, 2005 02:17:32 AM